Sunday, 27 March 2016

Racist stereotypes in Disney's Aladdin

Aladdin was a film that we all grew up watching time and time again. The exotic music, desert-like setting, colourful costumes and foreign characters, spun neatly and attractively into a typical Disney narrative, contributed to an ever present stereotype of Arab's. This stereotype of Arabic people, ingrained in our mind's at an early age, continues to build a division between the West and the rest.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TkbOGaJqJmg

The above scene demonstrates the typical features associated with Arabic people. The men chasing after Aladdin (who despite initially having a dark skin tone, ends the movie far whiter than before, signifying a movement towards becoming civilised, symbolised by the whiteness of his skin) are violent and frightening, wielding curved swords at the 'poor' Aladdin. He manages to outsmart and outmaneuver them at every turn. He dodges their thrusts and swipes, resulting in comedic relief at their expense, as their pants fall down or they are hit with falling barrels. This demonstration of violent, yet unintelligent men, falls in line with other representations of Arab's in films such as Indiana Jones (where a white, male lead outsmarts an Arab assassin easily and effectively). Another moment in the film that strengthens this negative stereotype, is when Jafar's sidekick, Gazeem, replies "I had to slit a few throats to get it" to Jafar's question about how he obtained the medallion. This dark response suggests the violent extremes he had to go to to carry out his duty to Jafar, and adds to the negative stereotype that portrays Arabic people as violent and dangerous.

However, the restrictive and inaccurate stereotypes seem relatively subtle, seeing as the film is set in the Middle East. Despite this, and as already mentioned, the protagonist of the film transitions from a poor, dark skinned boy, who is likeable yet lawless, to a lighter skinned, more civilised character. Aladdin eventually wins the girl by defeating the most vile representation of an Arab in the film; Jafar. The antoagonist in the film, Jafar is represented as both a snake, a cunning creature that we associate with danger and deception, and finally, a genie, who is chained, captured and defeated by Aladdin, who represents civilisation and good morals. These two negative representations of the Arabic antagonist contribute to embedding a negative view of Arabic people, especially men, as dangerous and ultimately, 'baddies' that need to be imprisoned.

The representation of Arabic people in Aladdin is negative and degrading. The one exception is the representation of Aladdin, who barely counts as an "Arab" at the end of the film, as his skin colour changes to a far whiter tone. Representations such as this, in children's movies, helps to set the normality of racial stereotype's in the minds of children from an early age, to the degree that we do not question their validity as we never recognised their origin.

2 comments:

  1. Nice read, i like how poor and how dark tone people is the equivalent to being rich and a whiter toned Aladdin... hmm I can recall a couple of old school movies where arabs or middle eastern culture are portrayed as bad people. The antagonist on True Lies (Big Arnie movie). The bad guys on G.I Jane (Demi Moore) and the bad guys on Kingdom of Heaven (Orlando Bloom) well not really, just that the enemy of the hero is the saracens. And also the persians on 300. All popular movies on mainstream media. I cannot think of any recent ones.. but these movies are made from the point of view of western culture. Apparently the template for all cultures (others) to aspire too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a great post and I fully agree with the points you have made. The Disney film Prince of Persia: Sands of Time, portrays the Arab in much the same way as you have mentioned Aladdin does. This is both interesting and alarming that Disney has this negative view of the Arab and it has the power to portray this view to children and people through the western world. Snakes associated with evil (Jafar in Aladdin) are also used in the same way with the Hassansin in Prince of Persia. Dastan (played by white actor Jake Gyllanhaal) marks a similar resemblance to the whiter Aladdin (as seen at the end of the film). This does all tie into the West and the rest idea. As well as this idea that the West can portray and represent a culture better than the culture itself.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.