What does Paul Henry being one of New
Zealand’s primetime broadcaster’s say to the country’s audience?
The racist comments of Paul Henry are
seemingly never-ending and unapologetic. And a lot of it he gets away with
because it is hidden under a veil of “comedy”. In my opinion, the very act of allowing
someone like Paul Henry to remain in such a primetime broadcasting position,
not only encourages his blatant racism and perpetuation of racist stereotypes,
but also encourages the rest of New Zealand to behave the same way.
How is Paul Henry racist, you ask? Let’s
count the ways.
1)
Firstly, and most infamously,
his extremely racist response to the, apparently hilarious, surname of Indian
politician, Sheila Dikshit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhRvmNyid24
2)
“I am not going to be
insensitive but I’m going to do some racial profiling here” Here Henry uses the
classic”I’m not racist, but”, before he goes on to make racist comments about
Asian people.
http://mananews.co.nz/wp/?p=7330
http://mananews.co.nz/wp/?p=7330
3)
This video shows Henry blaming
“Hispanic people who pick them” for tomatoes causing salmonella –“I call it as
I see it, if you’re Hispanic you pick tomatoes” Later going on to say, in a
very half-hearted apology, that he “certainly didn’t think any Hispanics were
watching.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JSTi89tJBA#t=108
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JSTi89tJBA#t=108
4)
When he asked John Key if the
Governor General, Sir Anand Satyanand, was really a New Zealander or not, and
if he was going to pick someone who “looks and sounds more like a New Zealander
next time”.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10678060
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10678060
5)
Here he can be seen mocking
Indian accents…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtPHjR__Y1A
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtPHjR__Y1A
6)
During his time on Australian
television he made many controversial comments about asylum seekers, including
these, which insinuate that they are “smelly” and “dirty” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2RMAxaI5jk
This list only compiles instances of racism
so overt that the general public took enough notice for them to be
controversial. From the various times I have watched Henry’s show I have
noticed that casual racism, the kind someone who doesn’t think critically about
race wouldn’t notice, is a staple of his show.
Paul Henry is an excellent representation
of white privilege. After all of these instances, he still has his own
primetime breakfast show. In the morning, it is through Henry that a lot of
people first hear that day’s news, and the opinion he presents that news with
is going to have an impact. If he is racist, and that racism is met with
laughter, and not a significant negative response (like, say, firing him for
good this time), that only encourages New Zealanders watching to also employ
that behaviour. By allowing him to continue to hold this position of power, we
are allowing someone to perpetuate harmful racial stereotypes – a lot of the
time not even in a subtle way. Additionally, his continuing to be on air says
something profound about the state of race and racism in our country – if this
is okay, what’s not okay? Where do we draw the line?
The way I see it, Paul Henry exists as a
constant reminder that as white man, it doesn’t really matter what you say,
people will, in most instances, forgive, forget, and give you your own
primetime breakfast show.
SO GOOD - Paul Henry is the embodiment of the white male who can get away with saying pretty much anything. Even if he gets some flack for one thing, he'll soon be back on one platform or another with another problematic comment.
ReplyDeleteVery similar to that sports guy who literally almost killed his wife and is still a revered sports commentator in NZ? Like what?
SO GOOD - Paul Henry is the embodiment of the white male who can get away with saying pretty much anything. Even if he gets some flack for one thing, he'll soon be back on one platform or another with another problematic comment.
ReplyDeleteVery similar to that sports guy who literally almost killed his wife and is still a revered sports commentator in NZ? Like what?
Classic example of how NZ media is so blasé about people who hold ridiculously racist views, another one who comes to mind is good old Mike Hosking as Suzanne mentioned in week 2. Our media is so powerful in suggesting how people view things, I wonder what impact would be made if radio/news presenters with constructive and fresh opinions on topics like immigration and Maori/Pakeha relations were instated?
ReplyDeleteThe intersection of comedy and racism is a very interesting one. For some reason, we esteem having a 'sense of humour' as an ability and more laudable that, you know, being respectful to one another. An interesting phenomenon embodied in Henry's Dikshit "gaffe".
ReplyDelete