Cultural appropriation and
the infamous twerk.
The infamous pop star, Miley Cyrus is renowned for pushing
the boundaries in the pop culture limelight but is also an excellent
representation of Cultural appropriation. Going off the blog I came across (http://www.xojane.com/issues/the-origins-of-twerking)
I want to discuss my own thoughts on her demeanour and how she utilises this
concept to actually heighten her fame and name in pop culture with specific
focus on her appearance at the 2013 VMA’s and the 2015 VMA’s.
Sure, at first glance it can be deemed a negative thing and
a white girl ‘trying on’ black culture but in the long run, tabloids gave her
the attention she was after and she was able to revamp her image through doing
such drastic and ‘outrageous’ things like twerking on a married man in front of
thousands. I personally have come to like Cyrus, as controversial as she may
be, I think her movement in how we perceive her has been one of success and
although she may have caused issues on the way, I like some of her more
acoustic covers and less mainstream songs. So no, this blog is not out to bash
Cyrus, but more of a positive critique on the pop star. Although, contrasting
opinions on her are welcome.
What I believe was her most contentious performance of all
time was her 2013 performance at the VMA’s, you all know the one with Robin
Thicke and the foam finger. It can be argued that she exampled cultural
appropriation here through her back up dances being of colour and her infamous
twerk that she quite proudly illustrated all over the show.
Oxford English Dictionary defines Twerking to be “dance to
popular music in a sexually provocative manner involving thrusting hip movements
and a low squatting stance”.
It is also claimed that the dance move originates from
African culture and moved on through hip-hop culture and so one can ultimately
say it’s a black culture dance move. And so when young and ambitious white pop
star Miley Cyrus displayed her twerking in front of thousands in 2013 she was
bashed for doing so because it was simply not her place to because she was
white. Even though this event was noted to be contentious, Cyrus managed to get
every tabloid and magazine talking about her all over the world and so I
question how intentional this performance was in regards to appropriating a
black culture dance move. Similarly to her costume/hairstyle at last years
VMA’s, Cyrus wore long dreadlocks, which again are adopted from Rasta culture i.e.
black/Jamaican culture and so again was deemed controversial and inappropriate
of Cyrus. It didn’t help her dreadlocks were blonde and so it could be argued
she was appropriating original black or dark coloured dreads to be a white
culture thing through having blonde hair. Again, Cyrus was given major
attention and coverage for dressing in such outrageous attire. Could it be
argued that cultural appropriation is intentionally utilised in industries like
popular culture and the music industry for attention and is seen to be more
edgy rather than acknowledging the culture they are attempting to appropriate.
Iggy Azealea, as another individual of someone exampling
cultural appropriation in the music industry. A white blonde female form
Australia tapping into rap/black culture through her music. I’m not all that
fond of Iggy’s music or persona so my opinion is a bit more biased to her being
a crappy artist but again, I would love to hear opposing thoughts on this. Do
you think cultural appropriation is purposely utilized in the music industry as
a stunt to gain fans and attention?
I think in the case of Miley Cyrus, as you have said yourself, that the amount of media attention she has gained in acting outrageously, or provocatively, utilising the twerking movements of African-American roots, can be put down to the appropriation of cultures. Nowadays so many celebrities are attempting to bring the spotlight back upon themselves and I believe that in doing so, they cannot simply 'be themselves' thus they grasp onto anything 'unusual' to regain the limelight once more. I think it is a problematic stunt for sure.
ReplyDeletePersonally speaking, cultural appropriation can be seen as a tool to gain attention. These controversies spark debates and get people speaking. For example, the stupidity that is the Lean On music video by Diplo - it was full of appropriation and people would view it to see it. It brought the views up aka more profit but it also angered many. Of course, when a white person does it it is simply seen as a way to share culture. What Miley, and many others don't seem to realise are the roots and history behind what they do. Their unwillingness to learn just makes it more acceptable for others to follow their footsteps.
ReplyDelete