Saturday 28 May 2016

Why are people voting for Trump? Are they all that stupid?

This is a topic that hits very close to home for this American.

Growing up in a conservative, republican household, I have always been taught and raised with certain ideologies. Both of my parents are conservatives and always have been. I was taught that capitalism keeps the country running, being a republican serves in everyone's best interests, and that liberals mean well, but have no real sense of how to run the nation. For my father, he despised the idea of the government helping our family. On a very low income and trying to support us on his struggling business, he was determined to make it work because it was his job - not the president's - to provide for us, even if we did meet the qualifications for government aid. In his mind, the liberal idea is to make everyone on the same page: regardless of income or hard work, the playing field should be leveled.

And he isn't wrong.

To some, that makes sense; to him, that's unfair. He struggled and worked incredibly hard to pay rent and keep a roof over our heads, put food on the table, and raise his kids alongside my mother, who also decided in recent years to get a part-time job to help out with the expenses. If he could do it all with so little, and no help from the government, why did Joe down the road get bailouts and food stamps for his pack of smokes and bourbon?

Trump is a lot of things to those watching around the world. A bigot, a buffoon, an imbecile unfit to run a country. He is intimidating to those not lining up with his "Make America Great Again" ideals, laughable to our international friends watching, and infuriating to those who feel his presidency would step on all the progress that has been made in the area of social justice.

But to many conservatives, like my father, he represents something else entirely.

He represents a fresh start. I think we can all agree that Trump is one of a kind. He is blunt, straight-forward with what his stances are, and represents the business aspect of politics and emphasizes its importance. Trump stands as a result of all the hard work my father has fought through all his life. He promotes himself as a politician like no other - as someone who can stand up and say the things that he does without fear of backlash, Trump is gutsy and refreshing. And with a slogan like "Make American Great Again," well, that's all my father has ever wanted for his family.

My father and I butt heads when it comes to political ideologies. Of course, we argue when the topic of Trump comes up. But that does not, in any way, make his opinions invalid. That does not, in any way, make him stupid. My father is the wisest and most hard working man I know, and has guided me through everything in my life, regardless of circumstance. He exudes qualities that I respect and demand in any relationship: love, strength and patience. I am one of his biggest fans.

So, the next time Trump comes up in the news and your knee-jerk reaction is "Pfft. Those Americans. What idiots!" - I urge you to think. Everyone's situation is different. You cannot know someone's reasoning for their political views without knowing what they've been through or believe. Instead of sitting in front of your television or computer screen with popcorn to see what crap-storm Americans have hailed down next, get up and do some research. Educate yourself on why there are Trump supporters. You don't have to agree with them - I certainly don't - but you should not assume they are all brainwashed imbeciles. We are all human, with our own unique human experiences, and while, yes, some are inherently cruel and racist bigots, the reality is the majority are not. You can think Trump is an ass, and so are his supporters, but be careful with assuming. Assuming makes a...well, you know....out of you and me.

5 comments:

  1. Really interesting post! I am originally from America as well, Arkansas in fact so I am pretty familiar with disagreeing on politics with family members, especially my grandfather. However I also get tired with reductionist views on why there are people in America who support Trump. You get a lot of "oh they must all just be stupid" which I think is a very narrow way of analyzing what is going on in the states. I have immense difficulty at understanding the appeal of Trump, but I have to concede that intelligent and thoughtful people endorse him. I recently went to a panel about 'The state of America' at the Writers and Readers Festival and there was some fascinating discussion about him. Gloria Steinem noted how she believes he represents a 'backlash' candidate. Basically how she sees the support he has gained more as an outcome of the women's and civil rights movements of the 60s and 70s, as well as subsequent movements away from white supremacy + patriarchy etc. I don't think that the support of Trump represents conscious racism/sexism etc. (though a lot of the time it totes does) but I agree with Gloria Steinem and feel that maybe his popularity has to do with the progress of recent years which has unsettled the hierarchy of white/male dominance, so people are seeking out some kind of caricature of 'relatability'. She also was very confident that though he has gained traction as a backlash candidate getting the level of endorsement to actually win won't happen, soo let's hope huh! Anyways that is one way of understanding the support of Trump without just going with "they're all stupid". Though he terrifies me I hope that (praying he doesn't actually get elected) down the line he will signal a break in the republican party and maybe a return to the more center/right it once was and goodbye to the facism/evangelical stuff. Maybe??! Anyways VOTE HILLARY <3 <3

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree! It is so, so important to look at the context as to why a figure like Trump has won so much support; the best article I have yet read on the American election was not an guessing the outcome of primaries but simply asking: why? The bottom line is there is a lot of anger and frustration over the way things are in the States, and both Sanders and Trump are appealing to this desperation people feel of looking for someone who can fix it; two polar ideologies, but the same approach. I agree with very little of Trump's rhetoric yet I understand why he represents so much hope for some people and I would never give criticism for that. Yes, he is a textbook example of white privilege and never would have gotten to this point without the invisible advantage this has given him, but I think this can be said of most politicians in the world and this is the reason why people feel increasingly cynical towards politics. Particularly in the racial perspective people feel as though there are very very few who represent minorities and/or indigenous people and their struggles with discrimination and oppression. Political discourse is overwhelmingly based on whiteness and white perspectives even in an increasingly globalized world. What makes me sad is that this gives such a negative perception of Americans on the whole which is unwarranted. I have an American Auntie and cousins and an American boyfriend, so I know how unfair and damaging this is because of the assumptions which get made.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very interesting to hear an American's perspective on the topic! I respect your argument regarding everyone being in a different situation and that you cannot assume the best or worst for someone with no knowledge of their situation. However, I think negative reactions towards Trump (in this country at least) follow his racist remarks. I think this aspect of Trump's campaign is what makes people question how someone could vote for him. Despite this, I do think this approach dismisses the argument you are making, in regards to Trump's campaign having a number of elements and that an American voter must question and consider them all in relation to their own situation.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great post, Arielle. It's refreshing to see some discourse beyond the usual liberal reductionist rhetoric; 'HE'S A SEXIST!, HE'S A RACIST! HE'S A [insert whatever buzzword you want], without any sort substantiation.

    While I'm not American and have no dog in this fight, I've found the road to the Presidential election to be incredibly fascinating, especially in regards to the Trump machine.

    What seems to be his biggest asset is his opposition: Hillary and Bernie. Both candidates being career politicians who have attempted to bank on hot-button issues and completely failed - Hillary's attempt to weaponize gender politics has been equally hilarious and especially condescending towards women who would dare hold differing views to that of her camp.

    Trump also knows that people are sick of slimy career politicians who flip-flop on issues whenever it benefits them; politicians that earn more during a 20 minute speech than the lower-class people they 'represent' will ever earn in a lifetime. Instead, Trump shoots from the hip. He says what he means. He doesn't apologize, and any attempts by the press to paint him in a bad light seems to be water of a ducks back; in fact it just gives him more free press.

    Regardless of conflicting views, especially in regards to him being 'pro-life', I think the man has shown a level of genius in his ability to manipulate the press and take away the spotlight from the others. It almost seems effortless.

    He may be a loose cannon, but he's one hell of an entertaining one. And he's got some great zingers: 'Low-Energy Jeb', 'Little Marco', and 'Crooked Hillary'.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.