In and of themselves, the events that occurred in Ferguson, mainly the lack of consequences for the white cops, made a very clear point about societies view on racism and how much we still need to fight, not only against it, but to have the general public recognise it as still being an everyday issue.
With these protests continuing alongside more deaths of innocent black men, the campaign online was getting more and more attention including the unwanted vocalised opinions of blatant racists. Infuriatingly, one of the responses to the #BlackLivesMatter campaign was the creation of #AllLivesMatter. This stemmed from the obnoxious thought process of;
"#BlackLivesMatter? What about us? Do we the WHITES no longer matter just because of a little racism? That is real racism! Claiming that only one race matters!! How about #AllLivesMatter!!"
and so on...
Many people do not see the issue with this approach and truly believe that by saying #AllLivesMatter, they are supporting racial equality. But it is important to recognise the true significance of hijacking the original social media campaign and what saying #AllLivesMatter really means.
What is the purpose of #BlackLivesMatter? This campaign was started as a way to acknowledge the fact that there is little value placed on the lives of black people, especially by the police force. With so many deaths of unarmed, innocent black people, #BlackLivesMatter was a form of peaceful protest in an attempt to point out that black lives do in fact have value and are worth just as much as white lives. While to some, this is simply common sense, the campaign was a way to try send this message to the whole of society.
What is wrong with saying #AllLives Matter? They do all matter! While it is of course true that all lives matter, our modern society has no trouble accepting the fact that white lives matter, we see this every day, but somehow still struggle to understand black lives in the same way. In this sense, saying that all lives matter is like asking for something you already have; its white people asking for their lives to be respected, even though that respect is there in the first place. One man created a fantastic analogy on Facebook; "My personal interpretation of Black Lives Matter vs. All Lives Matter. Bob is sitting at the dinner table. Everyone else gets a plate of food except Bob. Bob says "Bob Deserves Food". Everyone at the table responds with "Everyone Deserves Food" and continues eating. All though Everyone Deserves Food is a true statement, it does nothing to actually rectify the fact that BOB HAS NO FOOD!!" (Adam Campbell). Using #AllLivesMatter is down the same vein of "being colour-blind"; while it has good intentions, the reality is that those who act this way are really failing to address the issues of race in modern society by claiming they are already overcome and therefore, any action against racism is no longer necessary. It is turning a blind eye to what is really going on with the mindset that if our modern day and age is supposedly so liberal, racism must no longer exist, therefore there is no need to continue the conversation surrounding it. If you claim you are sick of hearing about racism, how sick do you think people of colour are of experiencing it.
The difference between #BlackLivesMatter and #AllLivesMatter comes down to this; equality is giving all people the same opportunity and expecting that they should all do as well as one another while equity is acknowledging that because of the way our society functions, prejudice takes away from the ability of some individuals to fulfil their potential, therefore in order to have everyone equal, some need to be given more opportunity or help than others in order to balance our society out.
#BlackLivesMatter exists because as sad as it is, even in our supposedly liberal age, some people need reminding.
Dedicated to, and in remembrance of those who died because of police brutality, including;
Michael Brown, Eric Garner, John Crawford, Dontre Hamilton, Tamir Rice, Ezell Ford, Dante Parker, Tanisha Anderson, Akai Gurley, Rumain Brisbon, Jerame Reid, Tony Robinson, Phillip White, Sandra Bland, Eric Harris, Walter Scott, Freddie Gray
I can slightly understand why the campaign #BlackLivesMatter was started. To show awareness for racism for black lives being killed for no reason but because of their skin colour. However, I agree with you when you started to talk about how this is stereotyping only black people, and what about white peoples lives too. #AllLivesMatter feels as if were all in this together and were not separating people by the colour of their skin. I also agree with your ending, it is sad that some people do need reminding that their particular colour in life, matters.
ReplyDeleteThe popularity of the #AllLivesMatter hashtag is such worrying proof of peoples inability to see beyond themselves. This kind of hijacking of campaigns aimed at social change do nothing for societies sense of unity and do not express the solidarity they might aim to, they express racist ideologies and a historic insistence that white people have to be the centre of everything - like the pushy Uncle that has to express his opinions on everything and anything even when it involves talking over those with more valid or informed perspectives. This post was super well worded and structured and importantly, informative! Seeing at this kind of new racism is often the hardest to detect and criticise, its cool to see it done so well and gives me some ammunition to get out in the future when i'm struggling to explain to someone just how problematic their 'inclusive' interjections into racial dialogue are.
ReplyDeleteI was going to blog addressing the exact same thing, but you've bet me to it. I completely agree with your longest paragraph. Everyone's lives are definitely important, however, those who are responding to the #BlackLivesMatter campaign with #AllLivesMatter don't quite understand the significance behind the original campaign. Yes, every life should be valued and treated equally. But the key word here is equality. The problem in today's society is that Black people are perceived as an inferior race compared to the others and therefore like you said, need constant reminding. Following on from the United State's police brutality, I do believe there are evidence of institutional racism embarked in each of the cases - where they (U.S. police officers) are applying the idea of hierarchy and degrading those who are black simply because they believe they are inferior. BlackLivesMatter campaign also goes to demonstrate 'Negrophobia'; shooting young black men because police officers assume they are/ will become dangerous. It infuriates me due to the fact that many still have trouble comprehending this problematic issue. Your post was well written and easy to understand :)
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete